Covers all matches played since the beginning of the 1938/39 season.
| Player | Gde | Opponent | Season | Venue | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SCHUMACHER, Bert | 7/31 | A | Blackwood | 1935/36 | |
| WATCHMAN, Harold | 5/6 | A | Hawthorn | 1940/41 | |
| SCHUMACHER, Bert | 4/18 | A | Sturt | 1946/47 | Hewett Oval |
| COULSON, Dan | 5/33 | C | Grange II | 1948/49 | Grange Oval |
| HACK, Warren | 3/15 | C | Belair | 1949/50 | Government Farm Oval |
| STUART, Dick | 5/28 | B | Long Range Weapons | 1952/53 | Narlutta.. Gawler Railway line.. |
| SIEVERS, Vin | 6/12 | B | Newton McLaren | 1955/56 | South P'lands, Sth Tce |
| HUNTER, Gus | 6/31 | A | Ascot Park | 1956/57 | Edwardstown Oval |
| HAYDEN, John | 6/18 | A | Y.M.C.A. | 1958/59 | South P'lands, Park Tce |
| MAGAREY, David (Snr) | 6/16 | B | Magill United II | 1958/59 | Murray Park |
| HUNTER, Gus | 6/18 | A | Fauldings | 1960/61 | Hewett Oval |
| MAGAREY, David (Snr) | 5/41 | B | Harris Scarfe | 1960/61 | South P'lands, Sth Tce |
| MOWATT, Geoff | 3/1 | C | Belair II | 1962/63 | Gums Oval |
| MAGAREY, David (Snr) | 4/25 | B | Super Elliot | 1962/63 | South Parklands |
| HUNTER, Gus | 5/25 | A | Fulham | 1965/66 | Hewett Oval |
| BESSEN, Darrell | 3/6 | A | South Road | 1969/70 | Edwardstown Oval |
| HALSTEAD, John | 5/47 | C | Mitchell Park III | 1970/71 | Blackwood H.S. |
| STRATFOLD, Neil | 4/54 | B | Kenilworth II | 1971/72 | Kenilworth Oval |
| HALSTEAD, John | 6/32 | C | Warburton Frankie II | 1972/73 | South Parklands |
| HARMER, Glen | 7/24 | D | Civil Aviation III | 1977/78 | Blackwood H.S. |
| KOKK, Steve | 5/56 | D | Coromandel Ramblers IV | 1977/78 | Weymouth Oval |
| MCFARLANE, David | 9/31 | D | Hectorville IV | 1979/80 | Murray Park |
| MCFARLANE, David | 9/31 | D | Hectorville IV | 1979/80 | Murray Park |
| DANGERFIELD, Clive | 4/17 | D | Kenilworth V | 1990/91 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| JOHNSON, Phil | 6/43 | C | Southern II | 1997/98 | Serpentine Reserve |
| CHEEK, Max | 6/10 | E | North Haven IV | 2004/05 | Manson Oval |
| LEMMEY, Mark | 3/5 | C | Adelaide Cavaliers | 2004/05 | Glenside Oval |
| NEIMKE, Darren | 3/0 | D | Mitchell Park III | 2007/08 | Blackwood H.S. |
| CARMAN, Liam | 5/29 | B | Morphettville Park | 2008/09 | Hewett Oval |
| HILLIER, Will | 5/19 | C | Coromandel Ramblers III | 2009/10 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| LOURENS, Josh | 3/52 | A | Cove | 2011/12 | Cove F.C. |
| JAMIESON, Matthew | 4/20 | D | North Haven IV | 2013/14 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| JAMIESON, Matthew | 3/36 | D | Southern II | 2014/15 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| ZADOW, John | 6/1 | B | Kenilworth | 2015/16 | Hewett Oval |
| KOIRALA, Jai | 7/30 | B | Kenilworth | 2016/17 | Kenilworth Oval |
| CHEEK, Sam | 5/27 | A | Belair | 2018/19 | Gums Oval |
| BROWN, Andrew | 5/20 | A | South Road | 2019/20 | Edwardstown Oval |
| LOURENS, Josh | 4/24 | A | North Haven | 2020/21 | Hewett Oval |