| 135 | SIMPSON, Brian | A | Kenilworth | 1967/68 | Kenilworth Oval | |
| 125* | ELLIS, Scott | E | St George III | 2006/07 | Manson Oval | |
| 102 | BURGESS, Ken | A | Keswick White Cyms | 1966/67 | Hewett Oval | |
| 94 | LANGMAID, Andrew | D | St George II | 1997/98 | Ridge Park | * |
| 85 | HOLLIS, Paul | C | Harcourt Gardens | 1977/78 | Forbes P.S. | |
| 78 | HANNA, Tim | A | Campbelltown/ANZ | 1997/98 | Newton Sports Gr. | |
| 77 | KNUCKEY, Kym | A | Westminster OS | 1987/88 | Blackwood Hill Oval | |
| 75* | FENNELL, Dan | A | ANZ | 1985/86 | South Parklands | |
| 74 | CORBETT, Duncan | D | Keswick V | 1984/85 | Hewett Oval | |
| 71 | MORLEY, Robert | D | Kenilworth IV | 1998/99 | Blackwood Hill Oval | |
| 70* | VANDERSCHANS, Arno | D | ANZ IV | 1994/95 | Thorndon H.S. | |
| 69 | TAYLOR, Mitch | A | Belair | 2020/21 | Gums Oval | # |
| 67 | MIDDLETON, H | A | Coldstream | 1944/45 | Hewett Oval | |
| 65 | MURPHY, Peter | D | Clapham | 2007/08 | Clapham P.S. | |
| 63* | GRANT, Colin | A | Grange | 1959/60 | Grange Oval | |
| 63 | SPRY, Simon | C | North Haven III | 2012/13 | Blackwood Hill Oval | # |
| 60 | CRANE, Jack | A | Grange | 1946/47 | Hewett Oval | |
| 60 | MCARDLE, Clem | B | Kenilworth II | 1967/68 | Hewett Oval | |
| 60 | RATHJEN, Peter | D | St George III | 1990/91 | Ridge Park | |
| 59* | KING, Matthew | A | Morphettville Park | 2025/26 | Denham Reserve | |
| 56 | BESSEN, Darrell | A | Kenilworth | 1969/70 | Hewett Oval | # |
| 56 | MORGAN, Wayne | C | Kenilworth III | 1983/84 | South Parklands | |
| 55 | KING, Russell | A | Mitchell Park | 2003/04 | Mitchell Park Rec. Res. | |
| 54 | GRIMSHAW, Ray | C | Keswick II | 1968/69 | Blackwood H.S. | |
| 54 | STEWART, Richard | D | Westminster OS II | 1993/94 | Hewett Oval | |
| 51 | GREENWOOD, Michael | C | South Road IV | 1968/69 | Belair National Park | |
| 51 | WASLEY, Scott | E | Campbelltown III | 1981/82 | Campbelltown H.S. | |
| 50* | KAETHNER, Alex | B | Hectorville II | 1999/00 | Daly Oval | |
| 50 | RYAN, Mick | D | Southern III | 1996/97 | Happy Valley P.S. | |
| 50 | BALL, Darren | D | Hectorville III | 1997/98 | Blackwood Hill Oval | |
| 49 | CHEEK, Darren | A | Mitchell Park | 1983/84 | Mitchell Park Rec. Res. | |
| 49 | HOLLAND, Shane | D | Westminster OS IV | 1998/99 | Paringa Park P.S. | |
| 49 | MAGAREY, Paul | A | Hectorville | 2000/01 | Daly Oval | |
| 48* | NELSON, Shane | E | Adelaide Lutheran III | 2022/23 | Manson Oval | |
| 48 | MOORE, Trent | E | Sheidow Park VI | 2005/06 | Manson Oval | |
| 47* | ARNOLD, Malcolm | E | Campbelltown II | 1984/85 | Hawthorndene P.S. | |
| 46 | ROWE, Ken | C | Keswick III | 1993/94 | Hewett Oval | |
| 46 | NEEDHAM, Patrick | E | South Road IV | 2004/05 | Clovelly Park P.S. | |
| 46 | THOMPSON, Sam | C | Western Youth Centre III | 2005/06 | Cowandilla P.S | |
| 45* | POPE, Jason | E | Southern III | 2006/07 | Happy Valley P.S. | |
| 45 | RAYMOND, Mel | A | Y.M.C.A. | 1950/51 | South P'lands, Park Tce | |
| 44 | KEEGAN, Chris | D | Grand Masters II | 2023/24 | Parklands, Park 21 | |
| 43 | DOYLE, Bill | A | Keswick White Cyms | 1961/62 | West Beach Oval | |
| 42 | ZADOW, Joseph | C | Plympton Footballers II | 2013/14 | Plympton Oval | |
| 41* | HARMAN, Tyler | C | ICC Sharks III | 2002/03 | Blackwood Hill Oval | |
| 41 | BORGAS, Neil | E | Norwood Union II | 1983/84 | Hawthorndene P.S. | |
| 41 | COWIE, Jarrod | B | Mitchell Park II | 1993/94 | Blackwood Hill Oval | |
| 40* | ROBERTS, Rick | D | Kenilworth IV | 1987/88 | Hewett Oval | |
| 40 | WRIGHT, Roy | C | Belair | 1949/50 | Government Farm Oval | |
| 40 | DAWSON, Tim | C | Mitchell Park IV | 1988/89 | Hewett Oval | |
| 40 | RYDER, Shaun | B | Kenilworth | 1999/00 | Hewett Oval | |
| 40 | CRAIG, Tom | D | South Road IV | 2001/02 | Ascot Park P.S. | |
| 40 | WEINERT, Adrian | C | Mitchell Park II | 2011/12 | Blackwood Hill Oval | |